Does Scarlett Johansson actually harbor a grudge against Blake Lively, or is this just another Hollywood-fueled tale of love, loss, & lingering drama?

While Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds currently embroiled in legal battles with Justin Baldoni, fans are revisiting the Deadpool actor’s short-lived marriage with Scarlett Johannson. Reynolds and Johannson were briefly married for two years before he moved on to the Gossip Girl star.

She was painted as the villain. Amid rumors of a rift with It Ends With Us director and costar Justin Baldoni, Blake Lively found herself dubbed a “mean girl” as they promoted the movie’s August release.