Related: Kristin Cavallari Confirms She Kissed 'Southern Charm' Star Craig Conover: 'I May Have Been Drunk One Night' Her new relationship also comes after Cutler, 40, went Instagram official with ...

Shep has a reputation for being one of the cast's biggest flirts and a total ladies' man. Ahead of the show, he dated Danni, whom he's remained close friends with for years. He has had flirtations ...